EE Times
November 7, 1994
Issue 822, page 1
   
   Copyright 1994 by CMP Publications. All rights reserved.

   INTEL FIXES A PENTIUM FPU GLITCH
  
        By ALEXANDER WOLFE
        
   Santa Clara, Calif. - To correct an anomaly that caused inaccurate
   results on some high-precision calculations, Intel Corp. last week
   confirmed that it had updated the floating-point unit (FPU) in the
   Pentium microprocessor.
   
   The company said that the glitch was discovered midyear and was fixed
   with a mask change in recent silicon. ''This was a very rare condition
   that happened once every 9 to 10 billion operand pairs,'' said Steve
   Smith, a Pentium engineering manager at Intel.
   
   A spot check last week indicated the problem is present in at least
   one recently made Pentium-based PC. Intel said it could not quantify
   how many such systems were in the field.
   
   Said an Intel spokesman: ''This doesn't even qualify as an errata. We
   fixed it in a subsequent stepping.''
   
   
   
   Erroneous division
   
   The issue came to light last week in a message, on Compuserve's
   ''Canopus'' forum, which was a reposting of a private e-mail
   communication from Lynchburg College (Lynchburg, Va.) mathematics
   professor Thomas Nicely. ''The Pentium floating-point unit is
   returning erroneous values for certain division operations,'' he
   wrote. ''For example, 1/824633702441 is calculated incorrectly (all
   digits beyond the eighth significant digit are in error). This can be
   verified . . . by computing (824633702441.0)  (1/824633702441.0),
   which should equal 1 exactly (within some extremely small rounding
   error; in general, coprocessor results should contain 19 significant
   decimal digits). However, the Pentiums tested return
   0.999999996274709702 for this calculation.''
   
   ''The bug has been observed on all Pentiums I have tested or had
   tested to date, including a Dell P90, a Gateway P90, a Micron P60, an
   Insight P60 and a Packard-Bell P60. It has not been observed on any
   486 or earlier system, even those with a PCI bus. If the
   floating-point unit is locked out (not always possible), the error
   disappears.''
   
   Intel's Smith emphasized that the anomaly would not affect the average
   user. Speaking of Nicely, Smith said: ''He's the most extreme user. He
   spends round-the-clock time calculating reciprocals. What he observed
   after running this for months is an instance where we have eight
   decimal points correct, and the ninth not showing up correctly. So you
   get an error in the ninth decimal digit to the right of the mantissa.
   I think even if you're an engineer, you're not going to see this.''
   
   Nicely said he pointed out the problem to Intel, because ''it has a
   major effect in mathematics, because we have to have absolute
   precision. I suspect that, to the majority of people, it will be
   irrelevant. But engineers may have a different outlook.''
   
   A spot check conducted at EE Times last week tested out Nicely's
   expression on an AcerPower Minitower Pentium/60 machine, which was
   just received from Acer America. The result was 0.999999996247.
   
   Intel said it discovered the anomaly through its own random testing.
   The fix involved a mask change to the Pentium's floating-point unit.
   Specifically, according to Intel's Smith, the correction entailed an
   update to the programmable-logic array (PLA) on the Pentium.
   
   ''This is related to the state machine in the floating-point unit.
   There are certain cases where, way out in the operation, we didn't
   handle the precision correctly,'' he said. ''It's an iterative
   calculation, and at each point, you have to go through a lookup
   process that says what your next approximation should be. For these
   rare cases, we made an incorrect approximation for the bits further
   out in the mantissa, [which equates to the digits] further to the
   right of the decimal point.''
   
   
   
   Better results
   
   The fix entailed adding terms, or additional gate-sequences, to the
   PLA. That corrected the erroneous results returned from the
   problematic lookup table accesses.
   
   Intel said there are no part-number designations or other markings on
   the updated microprocessors-which became available in the last few
   months-to differentiate them from the earlier anomalous parts.
   However, an Intel spokesman said, ''If customers are concerned, they
   can call and we'll replace'' any of the parts that contained the bug.
   
   
   
